Chat with us, powered by LiveChat Your executive director has tasked you with conducting some preliminary research on an emerging and perhaps even controversial topic in your field and then preparing a summary. These fi - Writingforyou

Your executive director has tasked you with conducting some preliminary research on an emerging and perhaps even controversial topic in your field and then preparing a summary. These fi

 Open all the attachments please. click on each yellow box for teacher comments

Competency

Critique research and research sources.

Student Success Criteria

View the grading rubric for this deliverable by selecting the “This item is graded with a rubric” link, which is located in the Details & Information pane.

Scenario

Your executive director has tasked you with conducting some preliminary research on an emerging and perhaps even controversial topic in your field and then preparing a summary. These findings will be presented at the next board of directors meeting in order to assess whether or not funding should be allocated for further study. You received little direction on what types of sources are expected, so you decide to begin the project by evaluating a variety of resources to determine how best to inform your project.

Instructions

Choose a topic on a newer or emerging topic in your field of study.

  • Use the Rasmussen library databases to locate a minimum of five peer-reviewed, scholarly articles, published in the past five years, on this topic.
  • Use a general search engine to locate a minimum of five non-scholarly sources, published within the last three years, on this topic

Feedback for student

7/15/23, 10:26 AM

Marie,

Thank you for your initial work on this assignment. You have selected a good topic and located helpful resources. I appreciate you filling out the matrix and providing a summary of your sources. 

I have made rather extensive notes on your paper relative to developing categories of your matrix further and re-formatting your summary into an essay, instead of presenting it as an annotated bibliography.

Specifically, I ask that you rework your Reliability column on your matrix. Nearly all of your examples show credibility. I have provided an explanation of the types of things that constitute reliability on you paper. I also noticed that when you do not see a bias in your source, you simply write "The article is unbiased" or some variation of this comment. The purpose/bias category serves two purposes: One, if there is bias you can identify and describe it; Two, if there is no apparent bias, you should explain the purpose/the goal of the article. As such, you need to develop comments in this section as well. I mentioned opportunities, as well, to explain relevance for some of your entries, clarify when authors are not listed (particularly in your non-scholarly section), and check for editing needs. 

In terms of your summary, please write an essay which integrates your sources into a discussion about credibility and reliability instead of list each one as if in an annotated bibliography. I also noted in comments on your paper that most of your examples have to do with credibility. Please be sure to provide and explain examples of reliability as well. 

Please review my comments on your paper and on the rubric as well. Please don't hesitate to reach out with questions. 

,

HSA5000 Deliverable 1 Scholarly and Non-Scholarly Source Matrix

Scholarly Source Title

Author Credentials

Intended Audience

Major

Assertions

Purposes or Biases

Relevance

Reliability

1.

2.

3.

4.

5.

Non-Scholarly Source Title

Author Credentials

Intended Audience

Major

Assertions

Purposes or Biases

Relevance

Reliability

6.

7.

8.

9.

10.

,

HSA5000 Deliverable 1 Scholarly and Non-Scholarly Source Matrix

Marie Jeune

Scholarly and Writing

Rasmussen University

Robert Neuteboom

07/13/23

HSA5000 Deliverable 1 Scholarly and Non-Scholarly Source Matrix

Scholarly Source Title Author

Credentials

Intended

Audience

Major

Assertions

Purposes or

Biases Relevance Reliability

1.

1

Bassan, S. (2020). Data privacy

considerations for telehealth

consumers amid COVID-19. Journal

of Law and the Biosciences, 7(1),

lsaa075.

Sharon

Bassan is a

director of the

health law

and policy

program in

the American

Civil

Liberties

Union in

Northern

California.

The intended

audience of

the article is

healthcare

providers,

policymakers,

and

consumers of

telehealth.

Firstly,

COVID-19 led

to more

popularity in

use of

telehealth.

Patient

privacy is

safeguarded

by the Health

Insurance

Portability and

Accountability

Act (HIPAA).

Also, patients

The purpose

pf the study

is to raise

awareness on

privacy

concerns

linked to

telehealth.

The article

does not

display any

bias.

The article is

relevant

because there

are still major

concerns on

data privacy

by telehealth.

The article is

reliable in

providing

verified

information.

The journal is

peer-

reviewed.

The author is

also qualified

and

experienced

on health

privacy.

Robert Neuteboom
These are examples of credibility, not reliability. Reliability focuses on things like study design, use of data gathering tools or practices that are consistent and vetted. It is also about inter-rater alignment, replicability of a study, and the methods used to determine the validity and accuracy of findings. Focus on these types of things in this column.

Robert Neuteboom
of

HSA5000 Deliverable 1 Scholarly and Non-Scholarly Source Matrix

should be

aware of

privacy

concerns and

safeguard their

privacy.

2. Clare, C. A. (2021). Telehealth and

the digital divide as a social

determinant of health during the

COVID-19 pandemic. Network

Modeling Analysis in Health

Informatics and Bioinformatics, 10,

1-3.

Dr. Camille

A. Claire is

an assistant

professor in

the

University of

Illinois at

Chicago. The

author has a

PhD in

Health

The audience

for the article

are healthcare

providers,

policymakers,

researchers,

and public

health

professionals.

The article

asserts that

lacking access

to digital

technology

can have

negative

effects on

healthcare.

The author

also reiterates

The author

does not state

any biases in

the paper, but

potential bias

exists when

considering

the study

focuses only

on the United

states,

The article is

relevant

because they

provide

current

information

on the state of

healthcare.

Also, the

paper

highlights the

The article is

peer-

reviewed,

which means

other experts

have

recognized it.

Furthermore,

the article

cites reliable

research

Robert Neuteboom
This second example is a sign of reliability, but you need to explain the ways in which other research relates to the current study.

Robert Neuteboom
This first point shows credibility.

Robert Neuteboom
the author provides

Robert Neuteboom
States – capitalize.

Robert Neuteboom
at

HSA5000 Deliverable 1 Scholarly and Non-Scholarly Source Matrix

informatics. that the

effectiveness

of telehealth

can negatively

be affected by

the digital

divide by

leading to

health

disparities.

meaning it

may not be

applicable to

other

countries.

importance of

highlighting

the digital

divide to

ensure

equitable

access to care.

papers,

showing its

reliability.

3. Hoffman, D. A. (2020). Increasing

access to care: telehealth during

COVID-19. Journal of Law and the

Biosciences, 7(1), lsaa043.

DR. David

Hoffman is a

law professor

at Duke

University

School of

law, and has

The intended

audience for

the article are

relevant

healthcare

providers,

policymakers,

Telehealth can

be an effective

tool in

increasing

care

accessibility.

Patients

The article is

unbiased.

Telehealth is

still utilized in

the present

day. There is

continued

evolution of

the legal and

The article is

a reliable

source. It is

peer-

reviewed,

showing that

professionals

Robert Neuteboom
Again, this is a sign of credibility, not reliability.

Robert Neuteboom
If there is no bias, explain the purpose of the article.

Robert Neuteboom
Good point.

HSA5000 Deliverable 1 Scholarly and Non-Scholarly Source Matrix

written many

resources in

policy and

health law.

and patients. utilizing

telehealth

have a right to

privacy.

Telehealth

also has

significant

positive

impact in the

present and

future of

healthcare.

policy

frameworks

for telehealth.

Telehealth has

visible

challenges and

benefits.

identify it.

The author is

a law

professor and

has written

many

journals on

the topic.

4. Wang, C. J., Ma, J., Zuckerman, B.,

& Car, J. (2020). The opportunities

for telehealth in pediatric practice

and public health. Pediatric

Clinics, 67(4), 603-611.

Jason Wang

is a

researcher on

pediatric

health

The intended

audience for

the article is

people in the

pediatric

The article

asserts how

telehealth can

be utilize to

improve

There is no

explicit bias

highlighted in

the article

from the

The article

provides

reliable

information

on telehealth

The article is

reliable

because the

authors are

recognized

Robert Neuteboom
utilized – word form.

Robert Neuteboom
Also an example of credibility, not reliability.

Robert Neuteboom
on

HSA5000 Deliverable 1 Scholarly and Non-Scholarly Source Matrix

services at

Salford

University

and also an

assistant

professor at

the same

institution in

the school of

medicine.

field,

policymakers,

and

professionals

in public

health. The

article

analyses how

telehealth can

improve

healthcare

and outcomes

in children

while also

highlighting

challenges in

implementing

family and

children care

especially in

rural areas.

Telehealth is

also vital in

delivering

preventive

care and

creating

platform for

patients and

professionals.

authors. importance in

public health

and pediatrics.

The article

also provides

analysis on

the

importance of

telehealth in

improved

access to care,

reduced costs,

and in

monitoring

chronic

illnesses.

professionals

in telehealth

and the

journal

publishing is

also

recognized.

Robert Neuteboom
As mentioned before, this is an example of credibility. Provide examples of reliability instead.

Robert Neuteboom
Okay, so what is the purpose of the study, then? Explain.

Robert Neuteboom
a

HSA5000 Deliverable 1 Scholarly and Non-Scholarly Source Matrix

telehealth.

5. Ellimoottil, C. (2021). Understanding

the case for telehealth payment

parity. Health Affairs Forefront.

Chirag

Ellimoottil

has an MBA

from Harvard

Business

School and an

MPH from

Harvard

School of

Public

Health.

Chirag is also

the Vice

President,

policy and

strategy of

The intended

audience is

professionals,

students, or

researchers

interested in

telehealth.

Telehealth has

potential to

provide

improved

efficiency and

care services if

there is

equitable

reimbursement

of telehealth

services.

The article

has no bias.

The article is

relevant to the

current state

of telehealth

which

continues to

impact

healthcare.

The article is

peer-

reviewed and

the author is

qualified in

research on

telehealth.

Robert Neuteboom
This is an example of credibility. Show examples of reliability instead.

Robert Neuteboom
Describe purpose, then.

Robert Neuteboom
the

Robert Neuteboom
of

Robert Neuteboom

HSA5000 Deliverable 1 Scholarly and Non-Scholarly Source Matrix

America

telemedicine

Association.

Non-Scholarly Source Title Author

Credentials

Intended

Audience

Major

Assertions

Purposes or

Biases Relevance Reliability

6. American Association for

Community Psychiatry. (2020).

Telehealth: A Growing Trend in

Healthcare. In Textbook of

Community Psychiatry (7th ed., pp.

763-768). Washington, DC:

American Psychiatric Association.

The

American

Association

for

Community

psychiatry is

an

organization

of

professionals

from various

health

Researchers,

health

students, and

health

professionals.

Telehealth has

the potential to

improve