Open all the attachments please. click on each yellow box for teacher comments
Competency
Critique research and research sources.
Student Success Criteria
View the grading rubric for this deliverable by selecting the “This item is graded with a rubric” link, which is located in the Details & Information pane.
Scenario
Your executive director has tasked you with conducting some preliminary research on an emerging and perhaps even controversial topic in your field and then preparing a summary. These findings will be presented at the next board of directors meeting in order to assess whether or not funding should be allocated for further study. You received little direction on what types of sources are expected, so you decide to begin the project by evaluating a variety of resources to determine how best to inform your project.
Instructions
Choose a topic on a newer or emerging topic in your field of study.
- Use the Rasmussen library databases to locate a minimum of five peer-reviewed, scholarly articles, published in the past five years, on this topic.
- Use a general search engine to locate a minimum of five non-scholarly sources, published within the last three years, on this topic
Feedback for student
7/15/23, 10:26 AM
Marie,
Thank you for your initial work on this assignment. You have selected a good topic and located helpful resources. I appreciate you filling out the matrix and providing a summary of your sources.
I have made rather extensive notes on your paper relative to developing categories of your matrix further and re-formatting your summary into an essay, instead of presenting it as an annotated bibliography.
Specifically, I ask that you rework your Reliability column on your matrix. Nearly all of your examples show credibility. I have provided an explanation of the types of things that constitute reliability on you paper. I also noticed that when you do not see a bias in your source, you simply write "The article is unbiased" or some variation of this comment. The purpose/bias category serves two purposes: One, if there is bias you can identify and describe it; Two, if there is no apparent bias, you should explain the purpose/the goal of the article. As such, you need to develop comments in this section as well. I mentioned opportunities, as well, to explain relevance for some of your entries, clarify when authors are not listed (particularly in your non-scholarly section), and check for editing needs.
In terms of your summary, please write an essay which integrates your sources into a discussion about credibility and reliability instead of list each one as if in an annotated bibliography. I also noted in comments on your paper that most of your examples have to do with credibility. Please be sure to provide and explain examples of reliability as well.
Please review my comments on your paper and on the rubric as well. Please don't hesitate to reach out with questions.
,
HSA5000 Deliverable 1 Scholarly and Non-Scholarly Source Matrix
|
Scholarly Source Title |
Author Credentials |
Intended Audience |
Major Assertions |
Purposes or Biases |
Relevance |
Reliability |
|
|
1. |
|||||||
|
2. |
|||||||
|
3. |
|||||||
|
4. |
|||||||
|
5. |
|||||||
|
Non-Scholarly Source Title |
Author Credentials |
Intended Audience |
Major Assertions |
Purposes or Biases |
Relevance |
Reliability |
|
|
6. |
|||||||
|
7. |
|||||||
|
8. |
|||||||
|
9. |
|||||||
|
10. |
,
HSA5000 Deliverable 1 Scholarly and Non-Scholarly Source Matrix
Marie Jeune
Scholarly and Writing
Rasmussen University
Robert Neuteboom
07/13/23
HSA5000 Deliverable 1 Scholarly and Non-Scholarly Source Matrix
Scholarly Source Title Author
Credentials
Intended
Audience
Major
Assertions
Purposes or
Biases Relevance Reliability
1.
1
Bassan, S. (2020). Data privacy
considerations for telehealth
consumers amid COVID-19. Journal
of Law and the Biosciences, 7(1),
lsaa075.
Sharon
Bassan is a
director of the
health law
and policy
program in
the American
Civil
Liberties
Union in
Northern
California.
The intended
audience of
the article is
healthcare
providers,
policymakers,
and
consumers of
telehealth.
Firstly,
COVID-19 led
to more
popularity in
use of
telehealth.
Patient
privacy is
safeguarded
by the Health
Insurance
Portability and
Accountability
Act (HIPAA).
Also, patients
The purpose
pf the study
is to raise
awareness on
privacy
concerns
linked to
telehealth.
The article
does not
display any
bias.
The article is
relevant
because there
are still major
concerns on
data privacy
by telehealth.
The article is
reliable in
providing
verified
information.
The journal is
peer-
reviewed.
The author is
also qualified
and
experienced
on health
privacy.
HSA5000 Deliverable 1 Scholarly and Non-Scholarly Source Matrix
should be
aware of
privacy
concerns and
safeguard their
privacy.
2. Clare, C. A. (2021). Telehealth and
the digital divide as a social
determinant of health during the
COVID-19 pandemic. Network
Modeling Analysis in Health
Informatics and Bioinformatics, 10,
1-3.
Dr. Camille
A. Claire is
an assistant
professor in
the
University of
Illinois at
Chicago. The
author has a
PhD in
Health
The audience
for the article
are healthcare
providers,
policymakers,
researchers,
and public
health
professionals.
The article
asserts that
lacking access
to digital
technology
can have
negative
effects on
healthcare.
The author
also reiterates
The author
does not state
any biases in
the paper, but
potential bias
exists when
considering
the study
focuses only
on the United
states,
The article is
relevant
because they
provide
current
information
on the state of
healthcare.
Also, the
paper
highlights the
The article is
peer-
reviewed,
which means
other experts
have
recognized it.
Furthermore,
the article
cites reliable
research
HSA5000 Deliverable 1 Scholarly and Non-Scholarly Source Matrix
informatics. that the
effectiveness
of telehealth
can negatively
be affected by
the digital
divide by
leading to
health
disparities.
meaning it
may not be
applicable to
other
countries.
importance of
highlighting
the digital
divide to
ensure
equitable
access to care.
papers,
showing its
reliability.
3. Hoffman, D. A. (2020). Increasing
access to care: telehealth during
COVID-19. Journal of Law and the
Biosciences, 7(1), lsaa043.
DR. David
Hoffman is a
law professor
at Duke
University
School of
law, and has
The intended
audience for
the article are
relevant
healthcare
providers,
policymakers,
Telehealth can
be an effective
tool in
increasing
care
accessibility.
Patients
The article is
unbiased.
Telehealth is
still utilized in
the present
day. There is
continued
evolution of
the legal and
The article is
a reliable
source. It is
peer-
reviewed,
showing that
professionals
HSA5000 Deliverable 1 Scholarly and Non-Scholarly Source Matrix
written many
resources in
policy and
health law.
and patients. utilizing
telehealth
have a right to
privacy.
Telehealth
also has
significant
positive
impact in the
present and
future of
healthcare.
policy
frameworks
for telehealth.
Telehealth has
visible
challenges and
benefits.
identify it.
The author is
a law
professor and
has written
many
journals on
the topic.
4. Wang, C. J., Ma, J., Zuckerman, B.,
& Car, J. (2020). The opportunities
for telehealth in pediatric practice
and public health. Pediatric
Clinics, 67(4), 603-611.
Jason Wang
is a
researcher on
pediatric
health
The intended
audience for
the article is
people in the
pediatric
The article
asserts how
telehealth can
be utilize to
improve
There is no
explicit bias
highlighted in
the article
from the
The article
provides
reliable
information
on telehealth
The article is
reliable
because the
authors are
recognized
HSA5000 Deliverable 1 Scholarly and Non-Scholarly Source Matrix
services at
Salford
University
and also an
assistant
professor at
the same
institution in
the school of
medicine.
field,
policymakers,
and
professionals
in public
health. The
article
analyses how
telehealth can
improve
healthcare
and outcomes
in children
while also
highlighting
challenges in
implementing
family and
children care
especially in
rural areas.
Telehealth is
also vital in
delivering
preventive
care and
creating
platform for
patients and
professionals.
authors. importance in
public health
and pediatrics.
The article
also provides
analysis on
the
importance of
telehealth in
improved
access to care,
reduced costs,
and in
monitoring
chronic
illnesses.
professionals
in telehealth
and the
journal
publishing is
also
recognized.
HSA5000 Deliverable 1 Scholarly and Non-Scholarly Source Matrix
telehealth.
5. Ellimoottil, C. (2021). Understanding
the case for telehealth payment
parity. Health Affairs Forefront.
Chirag
Ellimoottil
has an MBA
from Harvard
Business
School and an
MPH from
Harvard
School of
Public
Health.
Chirag is also
the Vice
President,
policy and
strategy of
The intended
audience is
professionals,
students, or
researchers
interested in
telehealth.
Telehealth has
potential to
provide
improved
efficiency and
care services if
there is
equitable
reimbursement
of telehealth
services.
The article
has no bias.
The article is
relevant to the
current state
of telehealth
which
continues to
impact
healthcare.
The article is
peer-
reviewed and
the author is
qualified in
research on
telehealth.
HSA5000 Deliverable 1 Scholarly and Non-Scholarly Source Matrix
America
telemedicine
Association.
Non-Scholarly Source Title Author
Credentials
Intended
Audience
Major
Assertions
Purposes or
Biases Relevance Reliability
6. American Association for
Community Psychiatry. (2020).
Telehealth: A Growing Trend in
Healthcare. In Textbook of
Community Psychiatry (7th ed., pp.
763-768). Washington, DC:
American Psychiatric Association.
The
American
Association
for
Community
psychiatry is
an
organization
of
professionals
from various
health
Researchers,
health
students, and
health
professionals.
Telehealth has
the potential to
improve